Review gating means asking customers how their experience was first, then sending only the happy ones to Google and steering unhappy ones to a private form. In Australia it carries real risk: the ACCC has described this practice and said it can distort the overall impression of a business if genuine negative reviews are never published, and Google’s own review policy separately says businesses must not selectively ask happy customers for reviews.
The safe approach is to ask every customer the same way, with the same link. This article sets out what the Australian regulator and Google actually say, what that means for the review tools you use, and how to ask without filtering. It is general information, not legal advice.
What review gating looks like in practice
Most review gating happens inside software rather than by hand. A typical set-up looks like this:
- After a job, the customer gets a text or email asking “How did we do?” with a star rating or a thumbs up and down.
- Customers who choose four or five stars see a button to leave a Google review.
- Customers who choose fewer stars see a feedback form that goes only to the business.
Some tools call this “review filtering”, “reputation funnels” or “feedback first”. The label does not matter. What matters is whether only satisfied customers are invited to post publicly.
Is review gating legal in Australia? What the ACCC says
The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) enforces the Australian Consumer Law. Its online reviews page for business does not use the words “review gating”. What it does say:
- A business may mislead consumers if it suppresses or edits negative reviews, or removes genuine negative reviews.
- Reviews can mislead when written by family, staff or people paid by the business, or by someone who has not used the product or service.
- Incentives for reviews must apply whether the review is positive or negative, and must be clearly disclosed.
- Businesses need to disclose relevant context so it is clear to consumers.
The ACCC goes further in its December 2023 report on online reviews and testimonials, the findings of a sweep of businesses and review services. Among review management services, it describes delaying negative reviews by first asking customers whether their experience was positive or negative, sending those with positive experiences to post a review and passing negative feedback straight to the business. Again, the report does not call this gating.
The report says passing negative feedback to a business may help it resolve disputes, but it may also distort the overall impression of a business if genuine negative reviews are never published. It also lists preventing negative reviews among the ways businesses may distort reviews to mislead consumers.
The ACCC has not, on the pages we opened, said that gating is always illegal. It has said the practice can create a misleading overall impression, and its page on false or misleading claims says it makes no difference whether a business intends to mislead or not. A star rating built only from customers you chose to invite is the kind of overall impression the ACCC is concerned about.
A worked example
Picture a plumbing business that finishes 100 jobs a month. Its review tool asks every customer for a score, and 85 give four or five stars. Only those 85 see the Google link. The other 15 get a private form. Over a year, the public rating is built almost entirely from the happiest customers, and someone reading the profile has no way of knowing that 15 in every 100 were never invited.
The numbers are made up, but the shape is the point. The rating no longer reflects the business’s customers as a whole, which is the distortion the ACCC report describes.
Google’s review policy: selective asking is not allowed
Separate from the law, Google sets its own rules for reviews on Business Profiles and Maps. The Maps user contributed content policy lists what merchants must not do, including:
- discourage or prohibit negative reviews, or selectively solicit positive reviews from customers;
- offer incentives such as payment, discounts or free goods or services in exchange for a review, or for changing or removing a negative one;
- pressure customers to leave reviews while on the premises, or set staff quotas for reviews.
The same policy says fake engagement is not allowed and will be removed. Google’s tips for getting more reviews say reviews must reflect a genuine experience and suggest asking through a Google link or QR code.
So review gating breaks Google’s policy, and in Australia it also sits uneasily with what the ACCC has published. Rules elsewhere differ, so a business in another country should check its own consumer regulator.
Incentives: where the ACCC and Google differ
This catches many businesses out. The ACCC’s page allows for incentivised reviews if the incentive applies whatever the review says and is clearly disclosed. Google’s policy bans incentives for Google reviews entirely.
In practice that means a prize draw for every customer who leaves a review may be acceptable under the ACCC’s guidance if disclosed, but it still breaks Google’s rules if the reviews go on Google. When the review is for Google, offer nothing in return.
What to do if your review tool gates by default
Many review request tools and CRMs include a satisfaction step, and some switch it on by default. Check yours this week:
- Send yourself a test request and answer it with a low score. If you are not offered the Google link, the tool is gating.
- Turn off the filter so every customer sees the same link, whatever score they give. If the tool cannot do that, replace the step with a plain review request.
- Offer private feedback as an extra. It is fine to also offer a way to tell you privately, as long as everyone still sees the public review link.
- Check your website. If you show reviews on your site, show a fair mix, or say clearly how you chose them.
- Write it down. Note when you changed the settings and why. If anyone ever asks, you can show you ask everyone.
Our guide to review management software looks at what these tools do and which settings to check.
How to ask every customer without filtering
Asking everyone can feel risky. In return you get a rating people can believe, reviews that describe real jobs, and a chance to reply in public when something went wrong.
- Ask at the same point for every job, for example when you send the final invoice or the day after the appointment.
- Use the same message and link for everyone. Name the job so it feels personal.
- Send one reminder at most, then stop.
- Fix problems first, then ask as usual. If a job went badly, call the customer and sort it out. Then send the same request you send everyone.
- Reply to every review, good and bad. A calm, specific reply to a poor review tells the next reader more than another five stars.
We cover the wording and timing in how to get more Google reviews, the automated version in automated review requests, and replies in how to respond to negative reviews.
Where CentriWeb fits
CentriWeb sets up review requests that go to every customer at the right moment from the CRM, with replies and reporting in one place. That is part of our marketing work. If you already ask every customer by hand and it works, keep going.
A short checklist
- Every customer gets the same review link.
- No reward for Google reviews.
- No pressure or staff quotas.
- Reviews on your website are a fair sample, or you say how they were chosen.
- Negative reviews get a reply, not a removal request, unless they break Google’s policy.
Rules and guidance change. Check the ACCC’s current pages and Google’s policy for your situation, and get legal advice if you are unsure.