How to Choose an SEO Company in Australia Skip to content
CentriWeb
Not sure where to start?

Tell us how the business runs. We'll tell you what we'd build first.

Book a call
For builders and tradesPreBuildMore homeowner enquiries, more trust, more jobs won. For sole tradersOwner CFOA financial operating system for owners who do the books.
Need something of your own?

We build custom software too.

Talk to us

How to choose an SEO company in Australia: questions and red flags

Questions to ask any SEO company in Australia, the promises Google says to avoid, the legal risks in reviews and content, and what to check before you sign.

To choose an SEO company in Australia, ask what they will do, what they will report and who owns the results, and walk away from anyone who guarantees a ranking. Google itself says that no one can guarantee a number one position, and that it never accepts money to rank sites in its results. A good provider shows examples of past work, explains their plan in plain language and measures success by the enquiries it brings you as well as rankings.

CentriWeb offers SEO as part of its marketing work, so weigh our view with that in mind. The questions below are the ones to put to any provider, including us.

Check first whether you need an SEO company at all

Google’s page on whether you need an SEO says that hiring one can help, especially when you are redesigning a site or launching a new one, and that a good SEO can also improve an existing site. It also recommends that many small businesses start with Google’s own SEO starter guide, because much of the work can be done in-house.

You are more likely to need outside help if your website is old or hard to edit, if you serve several locations, if you compete with large national brands, or if nobody on your team has the time to write and update pages. You may not need it if you have one location, a handful of services and an owner who enjoys writing about them. Our guide to what SEO costs in Australia shows what each way of paying buys.

Questions to ask an SEO company in Australia

Google lists questions worth asking any provider. These are adapted from its page and extended for an Australian small business:

  1. Can you show examples of past work and what changed? Ask for the situation, what was done and how it was measured. Names may be confidential, but the story should be specific.
  2. Do you follow Google Search Essentials? These are Google’s rules for how sites should behave. Techniques that break its spam policies can lower visibility or remove a site from the index.
  3. What results do you expect, in what timeframe, and how will you measure them? A trustworthy answer describes what they will do, what you should watch and how long it usually takes to see a change, without a promise.
  4. What experience do you have in my industry and location? A provider who has worked for dentists, builders or accountants will know the rules and the searches.
  5. Will you tell me every change you make and why? You should never be unsure what has been done to your website.
  6. Who will do the work? The person in the sales meeting and the person who writes your pages are often different. Ask who it will be.
  7. What do I own at the end? The answer must be: your domain, your website, your Google Business Profile, your Analytics and Search Console accounts, and the content written for you.

Promises to walk away from

Google’s page lists warning signs, and they are a good filter in Australia too:

  • A guaranteed ranking. Google states: “No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.” If a provider promises first place, Google advises finding someone else.
  • An unsolicited email or call offering to fix your SEO. Google lists unsolicited emails offering SEO services as a red flag.
  • A “special relationship” with Google or a “priority submit” option. Google says it never accepts money to include or rank sites in its results.
  • Secrecy. A provider who will not explain what they plan to do.
  • Link schemes or submitting your site to “thousands of search engines”. Google lists both as warning signs.
  • A request for full access before any work is agreed. Google advises granting only read access to Search Console at the audit stage.
  • Paying for local ranking. Google states there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking.

Google also notes that you are responsible for the actions of any company you hire. If an agency uses tactics that breach Google’s spam policies, the consequences land on your website.

Two parts of SEO work carry legal risk for the business that pays for them.

Reviews. The ACCC says it is against the law for a business to create fake or misleading reviews, or to arrange for others to do so, and that businesses should not suppress or edit genuine negative reviews. Any provider who offers to “boost your reviews” by posting them, buying them or discouraging negative ones is putting you at risk. Google’s policy on user-contributed content also bans paid and incentivised reviews.

Regulated professions. If you are a health practitioner, the Ahpra advertising guidelines say the advertiser is whoever controls the advertising, and that advertiser is responsible for compliance. The guidelines do not address SEO companies specifically, so read everything written for you before it goes live. The same caution applies to lawyers, real estate agents and other regulated businesses. See our guides to SEO for dentists and SEO for lawyers for the profession-specific rules.

What a good proposal contains

Before you sign, ask for a written proposal that includes:

  • What they found when they looked at your site, specific to your business rather than a generic report with your name on it.
  • The work, month by month, in plain language: pages to be written or fixed, the Google Business Profile, technical changes.
  • Who does each part, and how many hours.
  • What you must supply, such as photos, access, approvals and your own knowledge.
  • How reporting works, and what is in it. Ask to see a sample report.
  • The price, how it is charged and what is not included.

Reports should show what matters to the business: calls, form enquiries, bookings and, where possible, jobs won. Rankings and traffic are useful context, but a report that is all rankings can look good while the phone stays quiet.

Read the contract before the first payment

Check the minimum term, how to cancel, what happens to the work at the end, and who owns the content and accounts. A long lock-in with no way out for non-performance is a reason to push back, and so is a clause that lets the provider hold your website or accounts.

Small businesses get some protection against one-sided standard contracts in Australia. The ACCC says that from 9 November 2023 the unfair contract terms protections cover new or varied standard form contracts where the business has fewer than 100 employees or less than $10 million in annual turnover, and that only courts can decide whether a term is unfair. That is general information, so ask a lawyer to review a long or expensive contract.

Do a short check yourself

A proposal tells you what a company says it will do. A few checks tell you how it behaves, and they take less than an hour.

  • Search for the company’s own name and its own services. If an SEO company cannot make itself findable, ask why.
  • Ask two of their clients how it went, and ask what they would change.
  • Look at the websites they have built or improved for others, and judge whether you would trust them as a customer.
  • Check that the proposal mentions your actual services and suburbs. A generic proposal suggests a generic job.
  • Ask what they would do first, in the first month, and why.

Setting the relationship up to last

Whoever you choose, keep control of the essentials. Register your domain in your own name, own your Google Business Profile as the owner and add the provider as a manager, and create Search Console and Analytics accounts yourself and grant the least access needed. Meet monthly for the first quarter to review enquiries, not just rankings. Google’s starter guide says some changes take effect in hours and others take months, so give a change a few weeks, but expect a clear explanation each month of what was done and what you should see next. Our guide to how long SEO takes sets realistic expectations.

If you would rather talk it through before choosing anyone, our marketing work includes SEO, reviews and reporting, and we are happy to say when you do not need us.

Common questions.

How much does an SEO company in Australia charge?

Prices vary with the scope, the competition and how many locations you serve. Ask for a written proposal that shows the work, the hours and the price, and read our guide to SEO costs in Australia to see what each pricing model includes.

Can an SEO company guarantee first place on Google?

No. Google states that no one can guarantee a number one ranking, and that it never accepts money to rank sites in its results. A provider who promises it is a reason to look elsewhere.

What access should I give an SEO company?

Start with read-only access. Google advises granting only read access to Search Console at the audit stage. Keep ownership of your domain, website, Google Business Profile and analytics accounts in your own name.

Are SEO contracts covered by unfair contract terms laws in Australia?

The ACCC says the protections cover new or varied standard form contracts where the business has fewer than 100 employees or less than $10 million in annual turnover, from 9 November 2023. Only courts decide whether a term is unfair, so get legal advice on a large contract.

Related guides.

SEO and AI search · 6 min read

AI SEO: generative engine optimisation in plain English

Talk to CentriWeb about this

CentriWeb helps businesses get found on Google and recommended by AI assistants, and reports on what is working in plain words.

CentriWeb is based in New Zealand and works online with businesses worldwide.

Want this working in your business? We'll map it with you on a call.

A 30 minute call. You'll leave knowing what we'd build first.

Book a call